A cooperative approach to managing wild fires

-A A +A
By Carol A. Clark

Even as the San Miguel Wildland Fire continues to burn, it represents an evolution in federal fire policy.

“Managing fire is about more than fighting fire,” said Bandelier National Monument Superintendent Jason Lott. “Our goal is to allow lighting-ignited fires to burn naturally within fire-adapted ecosystems when we can do so safely, effectively and efficiently. Every fire is different, and we evaluate the potential risks and benefits of each one.”

Los Alamos Fire Marshal Michael Thompson agreed.

“Everyone’s recognizing that this is the better way to manage those wildland fires,” Thompson said. “It’s good to let these smaller fires burn, which act as fire breaks for larger fires.”

Bandelier Fire Management Officer Gary Kemp explained that fire and smoke are an inevitable part of living in New Mexico.

“It’s not a matter of if they occur, but when,” Kemp said.  

Several fires started in the Jemez Mountains during the first week of July. Of those new starts, all but two were suppressed.

“We decided to manage the San Miguel Wildland Fire for resource benefits based on guidance outlined in our fire management plan in combination with an analysis of the current situation,” Kemp said.

It all comes down to when, where, and why, Lott said.

“That fire started in early July, after the area had received substantial precipitation and during a time when fire resources were readily available,” he said. “It’s located in a fire-adapted ecosystem within the remote Bandelier Wilderness where it poses no immediate risk to life, safety, property, or resources.”

The fire also is surrounded by rocky terrain, trails and previously burned areas, which all serve as natural fuel breaks.

“That really is a perfect area for allowing the fire to burn naturally,” Thompson said. “In the townsite, that type of fire management is not possible so we use other types of mitigation techniques such as pile burning in the winter. We realize that smoke from fires allowed to burn can be an irritant to those people with breathing issues such as asthma but it’s a necessary part of  the fire management process.”

The San Miguel Wildland fire is playing an essential role in clearing out dead and down vegetation on the forest floor, setting the stage for new plant growth and helping slow the spread and intensity of large, intense wildfires in the future, he said.

“The San Miguel Wildland Fire is an excellent example of our flexibility in managing wildfire,” Incident Commander Robert Morales said.

“We were able to use a variety of tactics to limit the spread of the fire on a portion of the fire while continuing to manage the fire for resource objectives.”

As the fire progressed, hotshot crews and water-dropping aircraft were brought in. This limited the fire’s spread to the north, east and south where it had the potential to move into thicker fuels that would have burned hotter and faster than desired.

It also would have produced significantly more smoke that would have lasted for a longer period.  

“We focused our efforts on areas where firefighters could access the fire safely and where our resources would be most effective,” Morales said.

From the onset of the fire, Lott and Santa Fe National Forest Supervisor Daniel Jiron agreed to work together to manage fire for resource benefit as it progressed naturally from the Bandelier Wilderness into the Dome Wilderness on its western perimeter.

“This fire set the stage for future interagency fire management opportunities,” Jiron said.

“While smoke impacts were present during the San Miguel Wildland Fire, variable winds resulted in intermittent, temporary impacts to nearby communities during the most active days of the fire,” Kemp said.

Bandelier prioritizes public health and safety when planning and managing wildland fire activities in the Monument, Lott said.

“We have a responsibility to balance short-term impacts with long-term benefits,” he said.

Slow-moving, low to moderate intensity wildfires like the San Miguel Wildland Fire help reduce the future risk of large, destructive wildfires, which can produce heavy smoke and impact communities for weeks. 

“Fire managers on the San Miguel Wildland Fire are exceeding basic reporting requirements and working closely with the New Mexico Environment Department (NMED) to strategize ways to ensure smoke management is a priority,” said Rita Bates, New Mexico Environment Department Air Quality Bureau Planning and Policy Section Manager. “We intend to work closely together in the future to ensure that management of smoke remains a priority for all types of managed fires, including naturally ignited fires.”

The San Miguel Wildland Fire burned 1,442 acres on National Park Service land and 192 acres on U.S. Forest Service land and resulted in a mosaic of burned and unburned vegetation.

Fire activity has been minimal during the last few days and little growth is expected.

“Some logs and stumps within the fire’s perimeter will continue to smolder until extinguished naturally by rain,” Kemp said.

Final costs for the fire are not available, but early estimates show the cost of managing the San Miguel Wildland Fire are hundreds of dollars per acre less than a comparable prescribed fire or a full-suppression fire, he said.

In the future, the National Park Service and the National Forest Service will continue to assess naturally occurring fires as they did the San Miguel Fire to determine if they can be managed for resource benefits or if they should be fully suppressed.

If a fire poses no threat to life, safety, property or resources, fire managers may allow it to follow its natural course and cleanse the landscape and renew vegetation.

Both agencies expect managed fires to be more of a norm within the Bandelier National Monument and the Santa Fe National Forest.

For information about wildland fire in the National Park Service access, www.nps.gov/fire or www.fs.fed.us/fire/management/index.html for U.S. Forest Service - Fire Management. 

Contact Carol A. Clark at lanews@lamonitor.com or (505) 662-4185 ext. 25. Read her newsblog at www.newsextras.wordpress.com.